My friend’s wife "Cindy" is dying. She has about threemonths to live. They call it an environmental cancer: no familyhistory, no genetic reason for this horrific sentence. Somethingalong her path of life caused a few cells to go bad. So soon “Tim”and his three daughters will be navigating life without a wife andmother.

|

Tim is my friend, but he has also been my client for18 years. His father was one of my father's clients, so wehave had a long history with the family, as with many of ourclients. We simply take care of things. We meet toreview, we manage their risk and as their needs change, we makeadjustments.

|

Tim owns an automotive repair shop. A couple of years ago,his claims history was pretty poor so we had to move him toa high-priced program. If an insurance company sees atrend of increased losses, it's not uncommon to have to go to ahigher-risk carrier for a time until the claims activity settlesdown.

|

For the past two years, Tim has been paying a few thousand morethan in previous years, but keep in mind his carrier had paid about$75,000 for various claims over a two-year period. Tim’straditional annual premiums were around $15,000. After themove we had him about $22,000 which lasted for twoyearsTi'

|

Tim's renewal was coming up. I was using social media tokeep up with his wife’s progress. His last Facebook poststated that the doctors had done all they could do and thathospice would be called in.

|

Around this time, Tim sent me a note asking about the upcomingterm. Should we meet to review? My reply was no, takecare of your family, I’ll take care of this.

|

In fact, we were already taking care of “this.” Tim's accounthad been shopped to six carriers, and we had found a standard homefor his business once again and were back to his “normal"pricing.

|

I said that if he needed me to come to his house on aSaturday to review, I could swing by. Under the circumstances Ithought it best that I manage this for Tim as he was spending hislast few months with Cindy.

|

Tim texted me that he would like to see what we were ableto do for him and asked that I drop off a summary. I did andthe next day he ordered loss runs. No surprises -- every fewyears, Tim gets an alternate quote, but under the circumstsances, Ifound this a little perplexing.

|

My partner Ronn has a large motor home that he uses Tim’sshop to maintain. A few days ago when Ronn was at Tim'sshop, Tim confided that he was very upset with me. Maybe I hadoutgrown his account and Ronn should take over.

|

Ronn told him that garage insurance was not his specialty,that I was the best agent for Tim's account, and that he knew I hadbeen working for Tim behind the scenes.

|

Tim swore Ronn to secrecy about his comments and told him he wasgetting another quote, but that he didn’t really want to move theaccount.

|

This Tuesday, Ronn got a call from Tim that thecompetitor's quote was $1,500 less than ours. Ronn told him tohold tight, he wanted to talk to me first. So I stopped by Ronn'shouse that night.

|

The story he told broke my heart. Tim's perception ofmy management of his account was that I was no longer payingattention to him. I didn’t want to take the time to see himand I was not working to keep his insurance costs incheck.

|

The reality, or maybe my perception, was that I was allowing himfamily time. I had worked his account as we work all accounts,had successfully returned his premium to standard rates, and wouldsimply take care of the change as I had many times in the past.

|

I thought the last thing Tim would want was to meetwith an insurance provider, but that is exactly what hewanted. In hindsight, I realize now that Tim wanted adistraction. He wanted to keep busy.

|

Ronn and I visited Tim’s shop and had a heart-to-heart inhis office. With tears in his eyes he told me he thought I hadbecome too busy for his account. He had been concerned abouthis insurance for the last three months, but I had not advised himabout our plans. He questioned if we were even doinganything.

|

I apologized, explained my strategy and told him that that myactions arose from my perception that he didn’t want tomess with insurance at a time like this -- that I would, as Ihad in the past, simply take care of it.

|

After a few minutes, he said, "OK, let’s do this, but answer mehonestly: Are you too busy for me, or is our account too small foryou?"

|

I looked him I the eye and said, “Tim, you are myclient. My book of business is made up of guys just like you,some big some small, but I’ll never be nor have I ever been toobusy for you.”

|

The business meeting was over and for the next 45 minutes Timtalked about his wife’s deterioration and eventual move tohospice. It was a gut-wrenching conversation.

|

This has been one of my greatest lessons. At a time ofgreat anguish and pain, some people need a distraction. Myapproach of texting Tim and providing support through words was notenough. Tim perceived my handling of the matter as meaningthat I didn’t care when in my mind, I was taking something offTim’s plate that would allow him more time with his wife.

|

My experience with Tim should serve as a reminder that evencommercial insurance is a very personal business.

|

Want to continue reading?
Become a Free PropertyCasualty360 Digital Reader

  • All PropertyCasualty360.com news coverage, best practices, and in-depth analysis.
  • Educational webcasts, resources from industry leaders, and informative newsletters.
  • Other award-winning websites including BenefitsPRO.com and ThinkAdvisor.com.
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.